Transcripts
1. Introduction: Most painting problems
aren't paint problems. They're composition
problems that you failed to fix before
it was too late. Design and composition is a series of lessons
that give you a complete pre painting decision
system. Where things go? How close do you get? What stays, what gets cut? The one question that
drives every decision, why this subject you
will learn to read a scene before the brush goes down to simplify
what's too busy, to add what's missing, to use shadows and lead-ins to move the eye exactly
where you want it to go. This isn't a class about
having strict rules, but it is about making intentional decisions every
time before you start. So that composition and design isn't the thing that trips
you up at the finish line.
2. Tangents: So before we talk about what makes a great design
and composition, let's talk about what kills one. And these mistakes show up not just for beginners but for
artists at all levels. And that's probably because
no one ever names them. And that's what we'll do
in this first progression. So we will name each one. I will show you what they are, and then we will fix them fast. There are five offenders. I will show you each one, how to fix it, and
what to look for. Let's go. First one is tangents. A tangent happens when two edges almost touch each
other but don't quite. And sometimes they can
even kiss each other. So in this example, we have
the circle and the triangle. The fix, easy, overlap them. The second example,
we have a landscape. You can see the edge of the
mountain and the rooftop. This can be a tangent too, where all of these
lines come together. Nothing really overlaps. Ditto here for the
door and ditto for the side of the house coming down
and meeting the land. Typically in the landscape,
you don't have that. Affix. Simple. We just rearrange the mountains so
we don't have that angle. They no longer kiss. We can run the edge of the
rooftop slightly over. So we have overhang,
the door can come in. The land mass can go
behind the house now, and all that's fixed. So when tangents happen, the eye gets stuck. It doesn't know whether
these two things are connected or separate it sits there trying to
figure it out instead of moving through the image.
3. Symmetry: Next thing is symmetry. It feels safe. Centered subject, balance sides, everything even. That's exactly the problem. It feels safe because
nothing is happening. We can see that
here with the tree, and we can see an easy fix. A composition is
perfectly symmetrical, the eye lands in the
middle and stops. There's nowhere to
go. No tension, no movement, no reason
to keep looking. The painting just sits there. Expressive work needs energy. Energy comes from imbalance, from visual weight sitting
heavier on one side, from a subject that's
slightly off center, from a horizon line that isn't splitting the picture in half. So again, we can see symmetry
here, perfectly centered. We move it off to one
side, add a shadow, even turn it so the
labels are not centered, a much better visual design. Perfectly centered house,
trees on each side, a better fix, bump it over, a bigger tree, a medium
tree off in the background. We'll talk about these
more, of course, as we move forward, we just want to understand what
they are right now.
4. Horizon Lines: Next one is horizon lines. This is the symmetry trap applied specifically
to landscape. When the horizon line sits exactly in the middle
of the picture plane, you've cut the painting in half. Sky gets half, the
ground gets half. Neither one is important. We can see that right
here. These are equal. Every landscape is really a decision. What's
the painting about? Is it about a big dramatic
sky, thunder clouds, the golden hour, a
single streak of light, push the horizon low. This would give the
sky more dominance. It's about the land, the water, the field, push the horizon line high
and let the ground dominate. A
5. Equal Sized: Every object in a composition
is roughly the same size, nothing gets to be the star. Everything is equally loud, which means nothing
can be heard. Good compositions
have a hierarchy. There is a lead, a supporting
role, and a background. Size is one of the most powerful
ways to establish that. The biggest shape reads first. Everything else supports it. This shows up everywhere. The similarly sized palm trees, the same height, same
width, that's a problem. You can see large, medium, small work
better in a design. When you have this, the eye
doesn't know what to look at. When you have this,
the eye bounces around two of the
same size brushes, two different size brushes. This is more
interesting visually.
6. Copying the Reference: Camera is not a composer. It captures everything in front of it with no opinion
about what matters. That telephone pole
cutting through your beautiful landscape
probably shouldn't be there. That beautiful tree right in the center of the lens
with the horizon, right in the middle
does not care. The camera will keep that. When students copy the
reference exactly, they inherit all
of those problems. They paint the telephone pole, they paint the tree
right in the middle, letting the camera compose
all of their decisions. Your job as the
artist is to edit. Move things, remove things, add things, change the size of something, shift the light. The reference is raw
material, not a blueprint. You can see the shift,
move the tree over, move the horizon line down
some, added some hills. Much more interesting than this. The eye moves and takes this in. Here the eye gets stuck.
7. Assignment: Assignment one,
you're going to use this sketch as a starting point, and I want you to
fix the problems. There are many and there's
more than one way to fix it. The main thing about
design and composition is eliminating the five
things I shared with you. If you get rid of those, you're already in a
very, very good place. Take the reference, I
provided it for you. And do a two minute study, a quick sketch,
moving things around. I'm going to do the same thing. When you are done and
only when you are done, I want you to watch my
version of the fix. Again, it's not one
way to fix this thing, but I will share my
thoughts as well.
8. Robert's Take: All right. My fix. And again, we'll look at this real quick. I'll go over my thoughts. Obviously, we've got the
horizon right in the middle. We've got a bunch
of tangents going on all over the place. You've got a lot of similar
sized objects right here, and these bushes
even are equally distant from the
tree in the house. So that's another problem. And they need fixing. So the first thing I'll do
and I'll do this lightly first is but my horizon down. The house was in good shape, so I'm going to put the
house where it was. The two bushes here, I'm going to think about that. But let's go to the
next thing here, and that's those trees. To big trees sitting
in the composition. I'm not sure we
need both of them. So what I will do is let's take maybe a shrub
or a bush or something. Could be a huge
cluster of trees or bushes and let's sort of wrap
like that behind the house. And then over here,
let's take the tree, and we'll push it back
a little bit in here. And we'll give it some asymmetry
qualities here as well. And maybe we have
a little branch and it's got some
stuff going on. All right. Now we have the
mountain range or the hills, and we can sort of
bump those down. So let's just kind of keep
them really low. All right. So we have our big bushes
there, distant hills there. So already we're in
much better shape. So we've got those
two little bushes. We don't want them right
here, I don't think. Let's do we don't want a perfect little
bush there either. So maybe we'll put
one right here, breaking up that corner. And there, I really don't
think we need a second one. Let's just kind of
go with the one. Next thing I want to
identify is the clouds. We have a big sky area. But do we want to fill it with clouds if we have a big
shrub and a big tree? We can get maybe
some clouds in here. We do maybe a little
one back in here, maybe one off in
there somewhere. Then I'll just do a
big cloud In there. If I go over this a
little bit darker now, I'll start right
here with our house. Corner getting broken
up with the bush. That looks kind of nice. We have our ground plane back in here. Our tree coming down
a little bit in here. Small little cloud in here,
small cloud in there. Maybe a big cloud cluster there. Some big shrubs, mountain range. That is looking a lot
better than what we had. We got different size shapes. We got rid of the tangents. Everything is flowing,
and that would make for a much better painting
than this right here. That's not solution.
Again, there are many, but I think this would
work pretty well. I
9. Traditional Rule of Thirds: Are two versions of the rule
of Thirds worth knowing. The traditional one, you've
probably already heard of, the alternative is the
one I actually use, especially when I'm
working with a landscape, a cityscape, or any scene with a lot of picture
plane to organize. Neither one is right or wrong. Both are tools. This lesson covers
both so you can decide which one serves you better or use both depending on
what you're painting. First, we'll talk about the
traditional rule of thirds. This divides the
picture plane into a three by three grid
of equal sections, three equal columns,
three equal rows. That gives you nine
identical rectangles and four intersection points sometimes called PowerPoints. We can see them here, we can see the division are
nine equal shapes or spaces, and then the four intersections. I also showed it in a
vertical or portrait format. It works the same exact way. The idea here is simple. Place your focal point on or near one of those
four intersections instead of dead center. Off center is almost always more interesting than centered, and the rule of thirds
gets you there reliably, and we can see it here as well. Like I said before, it works for a lot of people and
a lot of subjects. It's a solid starting point. If you're just
getting oriented with composition and you need a framework to
hang decisions on, this is a reasonable one. For example, if you have a
tree we talked about earlier, we don't want to
put it dead center. We could maybe start
that tree right in here. And then bring it over in here. Obviously, we don't want to
touch that top like that. Focal point. Everything else is a supporting member
no matter what we do. Nothing else really
matters if that's going to be the focal point. It
could be our house. Maybe we want to put our
house right in here. Everything else is
a supporting cast, could be our horizon line, could be our mountain. Since we have a big sky, we could come in here
and put some sky. But that's our star right here, maybe a little path
bringing us in. You can see how this
arrangement works well. I'll just get our
main areas in there. And I'll darken
the edges just so you can see exactly
how that works. And the next lesson, we'll talk about the
alternative rule of thirds.
10. Alternative Rule of Thirds: So here's the version
I lean on the most, especially again for
landscapes and cityscapes. Same basic idea, divide the
picture into three sections, both horizontally
and vertically. But instead of equal thirds, you use unequal intervals. Small, large medium in any order that serves
the composition. For example, in this particular
design, we have small. Medium, large. These are our lines
here dividing it. That space, you can see is
small, medium and larger. Now, down the side, we have medium, large, small. Again, they can be flip flop, they can be mixed up,
it doesn't matter. So long as you have
different sizes, both horizontally
and vertically. Here's the same idea. In a portrait layout. You have large medium, then we have small medium. Same thing. We get these
intersections same as before. Basically, the grid
you get from combining those unequal vertical
and horizontal divisions gives you nine zones that
are all different sizes. Every intersection
point is unique. Every zone has a
different proportion. For example, if we took
this same idea of a tree, and we'll just put it over
here in the vertical format. Obviously, the center is bad. Maybe we want to put
the tree in here. We have our tree, and maybe
this section and here, horizon line, and we'll go
with our hills back in here. Then we have our
sky, which again, we can do a bunch of clouds, whatever we want back in there. Again, working with the shapes. Another way you can use it. Let's say you're doing a
city escape or something. Maybe you're looking at a building down a
street or something. Over on this side, maybe, again, the scene you're looking at or the photograph
you're looking at, isn't going to give this
information to you. Remember, we do not
copy reference, so we're going to use it. But this could easily be some building that comes down
in perspective like this. And who knows? Maybe it
sort of cuts off this way. And then we have
another building maybe over in here that
breaks in this area. Again, this sort of
maybe comes like that. This could be our street.
Our street comes in here and maybe this building, we'll say continues
up like that. Maybe we have some
perspective and here, whatever could be
windows, big doorway. Then this line
represents the horizon, so we can put our cars
different things in here. Again, using those
spaces as a guide. Organizing those
space, then this could be a different building in here, who knows? It could be a corner. We don't know. But again, we're using this space
for the building, using this space for
building horizon and so on. That gives us a very
interesting alternative way to organize your space. Let's have a look
at both of these. Again, traditional equal thirds, fixed grid, place subject
near an intersection. Alternative unequal intervals. Flexible grid, design the
divisions around the subject. Again, both work fine. Traditional is probably a little simpler and works well for students who are
just getting started. Alternative builds variety into the structure before it starts. So again, more flexible, a little more powerful for
complex scenes and for those that want to
try a different way. Neither is wrong.
Use whichever one serves the painting
you're making.
11. Scale: Every time you
look at a subject, you have a decision to make. Whether it's a
landscape, still life, a building, a figure,
doesn't matter. That's not what color to use, not how to handle the edges. The first decision is, how much of this subject am I including and how close
am I going to go in? That's the scale
decision, a long shot, a medium shot, a close up, it's entirely yours to make. Most students skip the
decision completely. They look at the reference and paint what they
see, all of it. Whatever scale the
photo gives them, that's letting the
camera compose for you. We talked about that earlier. This lesson is about
taking that decision back. Here is the key idea. Scale is not about
physically moving closer to or further
from your subject. It's about where you place
the edges of your frame. The same landscape can be three completely
different paintings, depending on how you crop it, pull the edges out wide, you've got a long shot. Move them tighter
around a specific area, and you've got a medium shot. Crop it all the way in
on one detail or object, and you have a close up. You're not changing the subject. You're changing what
the painting is about. So I'll pull up this
reference image. And I'll lay it out
three different ways. Now, I'm not crazy how the horizon is right
in the middle, so I will bump this
down a little bit. But right away, I'm going to just copy what
the image is giving me. So as you can see, we have some clouds and
things like that in here. And I'll go a little
bit darker here. Right so as you
may have guessed, we have a long shot. Same image. And I'll zero in a
little bit on this area. So that's going to pull
the road over here. And then I'll make the
tree a little bit bigger. So now we're getting less of the mountain and
more of this tree. That's our medium shot. Now I'm going to
change the format to a portrait and I'm going
to focus on the tree. I want to run it off the
page a little bit, too. I'll just suggest some sort of horizon activity back there. So now, p. That is through different ways you can crop the same image. But let's talk about this in
a little more detail here. So the long shot is about
context, environment, scale. It shows the subject in relation
to everything around it, the vastness of the landscape, the smallness of a figure
in a big city or space, the relationship
between land and sky. When you choose a long shot, you're saying the
environment is the subject. The mood is in the expanse. The feeling comes from
the space itself, not from any single
element within it. This works well when
the sky, the land, or just the overall atmosphere
is the real subject. It creates a sense of space, distance, solitude,
and grandeur. Individual details
become less subordinate. They support the whole rather
than demanding attention. Value masses and big shapes, do all the heavy lifting, and again, detail is minimal. A medium shot is
about relationships. It's close enough to see
specific elements clearly, but not far enough
back to show how they interact with each other or
with the space around them. A tree and let's say, a shadow it casts a building in the
street in front of it, a still life grouping with
the surface it sits on. And some sort of
background behind it. The medium shot gives you room to tell a story between
two or more elements. This is more of a common
compositional choice because it gives you the most to work with enough
context, excuse me, enough context to
establish a scene enough proximity to make
specific things matter, like we did here
with the tree and maybe even the
cloud in the road. It works well when the relationships between
elements is the subject. Shadows cast light, negative
space between objects, all readable at this scale. Enough detail to be specific
enough space to breathe. The small medium space
we talked about in the previous lesson,
is useful here. You've got multiple elements to distribute across
the picture plane. Here, we can almost see a
small, medium, a large. Here we can see a medium. If I did that, let's
say like this, and then I went across
here and then here. I'll do it a little bit darker and I'll catch
the top of these hills. We've got small medium, large. Then we have large, small, medium, catching the horizon,
top of the mountains. Close ups, it's all about
texture, detail, intimacy. When you crop it tight, individual elements
fill the frame. Edges bleed off the picture
plane, context disappears. What's left is shape, texture, and a specific
quality of one thing. A close up of tree bark becomes a landscape
kind of in its own. The ridges and valleys, the light catching the edges, the deep shadows,
and its crevices. So I could have gone in
even closer if I wanted to. But in relationship that is a close up compared to
what we were working with. So close up, let's say a coffee mug becomes
about the rim, the handle, the glaze,
the reflection. The subject becomes almost
abstract at close range. Students often
overlook the close up because it feels limiting. You're cutting out so much. But what you're actually
doing is committing. You're saying this
specific thing is interesting enough to
fill rather the whole frame. This works well when textures
and surface quality of a specific detail a subject has and it becomes interesting. Objects bleed off the edges, and you probably
don't want to try to fit everything in when
you do a close up. Abstract qualities emerge
naturally at close up range. Requires a commitment. The whole painting rests on one area being interesting
enough to carry it. So one more thing before we go is the y drives the choice. Every scale decision comes
back to the same question. What are you trying to say? If the answer is about vastness, isolation, atmosphere,
long shot, if the answer is about a specific relationship between two elements, a medium shot. If the answer is about
texture, surface, or the intimate quality
of one thing, close up. The reference doesn't answer
that question. You do. And until you answer it, you're just copying whatever
the camera gives you.
12. Assignment: All right, welcome to
the next assignment. This assignment combines what we learned here about
the rule of thirds. Remember you have two
options and then scale. And again, I don't care
if you use traditional or alternative in terms of the rule of thirds,
that's totally up to you. So I have a reference image. It's a landscape, and
we're going to make three thumbnails from
the same reference. Each one a different scale. Thumbnail one will be a long shot Number two will be medium and
then a close up. I will provide the
image for you. And then, of course, I'm going to complete
the same exercise.
13. Robert's Take Assignment 2: Okay, here's my take. I'll go ahead and
lay out my frames. I kind of have an idea
what I want to do. And for this one, I want to go I think I'm going to go more of a portrait
there. All right. So the long shot, pretty simple. Again, it has the horizon
right in the middle. I'm not a fan of that.
I'm going to come down. And the rule of thirds
might be fine here. But what I will do is I'm going
to go a little bit larger here than I will do I think
I'm going to do small. Actually, I'll do
more medium here. I'm doing large, medium, small. Left to right, I don't have
a lot to work with there. What I will do is go small, medium, and then large,
small, medium, large. Again, I'll make my edges a little bit darker so you
see what I'm doing here. I am going to put
this area right here. In the medium. And then
we have our home in here. And again, we don't
need to get too detailed with this
stuff right now. You know, the idea
really is just to not draw a perfect drawing, but more about understanding how these shapes fit in there. And we have another
little building here. Again, I'm not going
to get too specific. So we have our lighthouse,
something like that, and then the
background, the ocean, and then in here, I'm going to suggest some of those rocks. And, of course, we have clouds. We want to kind of capture a little bit of that atmosphere. Okay. So this could
easily be my long shot. Moving on. I'm going to go with
my medium shot, and I'll go small. I'll go small here, medium again, and then large. So small, medium, large. And I'll go sort of
large here on the left. Then we'll go small
and then medium. So we have large, small, medium, and then again,
large, medium, small. Now, we don't have to
squeeze everything in there, I just gives me a guideline. So with this one, and we have the house or
the lighthouse rather. And this angle, you know, very rocky sort of
angle like that. And then I want the we have
these smaller dwellings here. I'm going to place
a big vertical. And here. And we're not gonna
get all of it. And then we have one more
small dwelling here. So, again, this sort
of shows more detail, more about the lighthouse and
the structures themselves, picking up a few more
details about those. And then we've got some
rocks, different things, and we can even catch, you know, a few clouds
and things like that. So a medium shot. And here, a close up. My close up will be about
the top of the lighthouse. So I'm going to go small, medium large, so small, medium, small, medium, large. Not going to matter
much in here. But I will say let's
go small at the top, medium, and then large. It doesn't matter too much here, so So I'm catching the
top of that lighthouse. That little spire there.
I'll run that off. So now, my eye is automatically
going to these details. The railing. What's happening inside
this little glass area? I'm going to put the light
source on this side, just so I can show a
little texture here. Let me have one more little detail here
on the lighthouse. Now I'll even put a little
figure up here for interest, maybe gazing out. Okay. So that's my take. Again, it could have been
done many different ways.
14. The Why: Every lesson to
this point has all been about decisions
where things go, what scale, how to use
the rule of thirds, alternative rule of thirds, how big does it need to
be, that sort of thing. All of that is real, and all of that matters. But none of those things answer the most
important question. Really the one that has to come before any of those
decisions are made. And truthfully, the one
very few people ask at all. Why this subject. It looked like a good subject. I like the light. No. Oh, I thought it would be interesting. Those are really non answers. The why is just more specific. The thing that made you stop. So the thing your eye kept going back to and the thing that would make the painting feel incomplete
if it wasn't included. Find that and every
compositional decision we've talked about
now has a job to do. It's in service to the Y, and without it, we're
just rearranging things. For example, a bottle of glue, maybe this glue was sitting on the table against a
very dark background. The tan color was sort
of popping against it. Maybe the light was hitting
the red and giving me a certain reflection,
a highlight. Maybe the labeling with the
black bold outline around it, the red against the tan. Those are very specific things. So if I were to paint
that, that's important. I need to include that the tan can maybe I like the contrast between the light blue and the red and that little bit of brown in there
against the blue. This little circle
logo, diagonal writing. Maybe hinting and suggesting at each of those things is my why. Again, very specific. So if I wanted to
paint those things, I would have to consider scale. How close do I need to be? I probably need to think about the thirds or the
alternative rule of thirds. How is it going to fit
on my canvas or surface? Does the painting
need to be portrait? Does it need to be landscape? Which one best serves
that specific thing? What to include and not include. So if I'm painting this, do I really need to include
every single detail, every single word or
just suggest the red, a little bit of the black,
some of the writing. A little bit of this highlight. Do I need to include
the whole bottle? And there's also things
like exaggeration. Do I really want
to pop that blue? Do I want to make that
red supersaturated? And do I need to
copy and include every single letter or just
hint at this diagonal font? So those are just some
of the things I would consider that would help me enhance and bring out
the y in the painting. And something we'll
talk about later is you may like a particular scene
or object or something, and it doesn't quite give
you a strong enough why, but the bones are there. And in that case, we need
to fill in that blank, and that's when we come to
a more creative decision. So again, we'll talk about that a little more
in detail later on. So to be clear, before you start any painting,
answer this question. This painting is about blank. Fill that in, and I promise you, the rest of those decisions
become automatic, much easier to make. So let's sketch
some ideas out and I'll go over exactly what
I just shared with you.
15. Developing The Why: All right. I'm going to work
with the ten can first. I can even go with
a square format. Because I'm not dealing with a ton of mileage and scenery, I can keep the thirds
fairly simple. The main thing I
don't want to do at this point is put it
right in the middle, put it too close to
an edge where I have a tangent or some awkward space. Since the shadow was
casting this way, I think I can easily space it about right
here and bring it in. Now, the main thing I
want to ask myself again, and what we're talking
about is the why. Again, if I like
this brown against the red and the blue
ribbon there coming down, and maybe capture just a
little bit of that text. That's what I like about this.
This should do just fine. I just want to make sure
that I'm in close enough. I can capture those
things and I want to make sure that I don't like split
the composition in half. Maybe I want to run
this angle down in here and then we have
our shadow like that. When you're doing
these, something I haven't mentioned yet, we don't need to capture
every single detail. All you need to do is
work out the main ideas. At this point, I've
got my blue in there. I've got my label. It fits inside my
space, just fine. I should easily be able
to capture the writing. So we have our hot and then our chocolate
coming down in here. All that should fit fine. I don't need to capture every single thing
because first of all, this is all in shadow anyway. We'll talk a little more
about shadow planes later on. But basically, I would
I know now that this gives me everything that
I need right there. So again, I understood my why. I wasn't just talking
about the can. It was something a
little more specific. Who am I to say that
can be the thing? If that's something
that excites you, then I will say just try to find an appealing
way to create it. Make sure you're not making the mistakes that many artists make with cropping and so forth. Let's look at the
next thing. I think I had the glue here. I think this would work fine. You know, traditional
portrait sort of layout. I'll get my angle. Maybe
I'll change it like this. Shadows going this way. I like that kind of yellow hue against
the dark background. I like this red and the white. I like the red against
the tan as well. I just need to make sure I
don't make it too small, that I wouldn't really be
able to capture those things. So maybe bringing
it maybe in here. I'll get all of this in place real quick. Now, I can look at our label, sort of wrapping around
like this coming down. I know now, that feels good. I'm going to be able to
capture that red. No problem. So this composition
would work fine. I've got my dark
background there in place. We have our cast shadow
moving off here. So something like that
should work great. Again, making sure I create this composition and
think about this why before anything
hits the paper. That's the key. This would work. If I was ready to
paint right now. I could easily get to
work and feel good about these and know exactly
where I'm going with it. Now that painting would have
a little more intention. It would have a
little more momentum going into it before, again, I even mix
my first color. Time well spent.
16. Assignment: Okay. For this assignment,
we've got three parts. First of all, pick a subject. It can be something
out of your garage. It can be a landscape reference, anything, but it has
to be your subject. So don't copy what I do. Now, look at your subject and don't start
drawing it right away. Spend 30 seconds
just looking at it. Ask yourself, what is it about this specific thing
that made me pick it? What would make the painting feel wrong if it wasn't there? That's a very
individual thing too. I feel like 15, 20 people could look
at the same image, especially a landscape or a cityscape or
something and come up with many different
reasons to paint it, but attracts you to
this particular scene. Write it down in one sentence. Be specific and visual. If the sentence could apply
to ten different subjects, it's not specific enough yet. Now, the next part to the
assignment is to build it. A two minute thumbnail. Every decision,
scale, intervals, rule of thirds,
traditional alternative. What's in the frame? What's out? Does everything
help me communicate the sentence that
we wrote first? Don't try to make
a complete drawing with every single detail. Just get the big idea down in a way that clearly
communicates the why. The last part is check it. Look at the thumbnail you do. Does it communicate the why? If someone looked at it
without reading your sentence, would they feel what
drew you to the subject? If yes, that's a composition. If no, what decision is working against the Y
and then try to fix it. So that's going to be
your assignment three, and then I'm going to do
my own image as well.
17. Robert's Take on The Why: So here is the original image, and my first thought was, I love the colors,
the yellow building, the red rooftop on
the one on the right. Shadows are looking nice. But as I looked a little closer, I really liked how this road had the subtle sea curve down
to the trees on the harbor. So that meant I
needed to get rid of a lot of the clutter
that I just didn't need. And I tried it in
a square format, which I thought worked
pretty well, too. So this is after I
cropped the image, and that really helped a lot. Now I could see it a
little more clearly. And I thought at
this point, yeah, I just understate the
buildings on the right. I don't need much there, really emphasize
the s of the road, and I could even exaggerate
the trees at the end, even make them green if I
didn't want that fall look. Let's get into the design here. So the painting is about
that C of the road, the curve that takes
you to the trees. So there it is. My why for painting this. I could look at
this thing tomorrow and maybe come up with
something totally different. I honestly think another
square should do it. I'm thinking of small
over here. Small. Maybe medium. And then large. So we need a lot of space over here to get
that curve in there. And then maybe medium. Small. Large. So something
like that should get us there. So our sweet spot
is right in here. This was where the
trees would live. So that C kind of
comes like this. Well, let me kind of
get this one first. It comes out here. Then we've got this
sort of shape. So there's our kind of C. So we're doing this
kind of a backward C. We got a little
a background here, so I'm not really too
concerned about that, though. So we have our
small shape over in here so I can catch a little
bit of this building, doesn't need to be much, something to sort
of fill in the gap. We have a truck over here. I'm just going to put
a box foreground, we can do this other box. And then I don't really
need every single car, so I'll just do a couple that kind of lead
us to the trees, one, two, three, takes us right into these strong
verticals in here. I'll just do an outline
of those trees. Now, again, we got
a ton of buildings, so I'm going to downplay those. They don't really
matter a whole lot. I'll just do some
shapes and then maybe catch this one larger
building in here. And it's got some detail. I can do some
perspective, whatever. And then again, these
cars and all that stuff, they would be downplayed
a little bit. So there's my boom, boom, trees, against
the light blue. Again, I'm not worried about painting every single
building here. That would be a mistake anyway. I would do just enough
to sort of capture it. But of course, I feel like that kind of
sells the idea pretty good. Like this gets us in here, takes us right into
here to those trees. And I feel like if someone
were to see that, you know, they would maybe feel that as well. A
18. Shadow Connections: Most students treat
shadows as something that happens after the
composition is figured out. You build the scene, then you add the shadows where they fall. This lesson flips that. Shadows are a design tool. One of the most
powerful ones you have actually, they
connect things. They unify a painting. And when you use
them intentionally, they pull the viewer's eye exactly where you want it to go. We're also going to
talk about lead-ins. The idea of something
in the foreground can act as a road
into the painting, bringing the viewer in from the edge of the frame or
perhaps from the foreground, delivering them to the Y. So two ideas, one job, move the I with intention. So here's the problem
shadow solve. Separate objects in a
composition can feel like they're just sitting
next to each other, unrelated. We see that here. They share a frame,
but not a painting. The eye bounces between them without knowing where to land. A well placed shadow fixes that. When a cast shadow from one object runs across the surface and touches
another object, it creates a visual bridge. Those two things are
now in a relationship. The painting holds
together better. Shadows simplify. So let's just see
how that would work. So we'll put the light
source over here. And I'll just add a little
shadow just to indicate that. So we have that connection. That shadow could move up. And over that one. And then this would have a little
casado a little paint brush. So hopefully, you can
see that these are now more visually
connected than they were. Same can be said
for a landscape. All these little bushes, trees, nothing is connected. We don't have to connect
every single thing. The idea is to connect
as many as you can, that makes sense to bring a little more simplification really to the
design, composition. So we're going to put the
light source over here. I'll just add a little value. Of course, we'll have
some value on the leaves. Okay, so shadow coming over, maybe coming across the
path connecting these two. The shrub, just getting a little cast shadow to
connect to the path. Maybe touching here,
barely touching, maybe. This cast shadow
touching the tree. Now we have a connection there. Or a little rock or
bush or whatever. Again, connecting that path. Maybe barely getting to the
outside of that frame here. So now the shapes connect to
other objects and things. In short, shadows also simplify, which I talked about before. A complicated scene
with too much going on, can be unified by large
shadow masses that pull several elements into one dark shape, which
is what we did here. Suddenly, there are
three big values instead of ten competing ones. The eye knows what to do. And
19. Foreground Shadows: A foreground shadow running diagonally toward a subject is one of the oldest
compositional moves in painting, and it still works because it works with how the
eye naturally moves. When a strong diagonal shadow enters a frame from a corner or edge and points towards the focal point or leads
the viewer's eye in, then that is a connector. They don't decide to follow
it, they just do it. The diagonal creates
momentum and the shadow delivers
them into the y. Think of a long afternoon
shadow stretching across the road towards
a barn in the distance. The shadow is the lead in. The barn is the destination. The viewer travels the shadow without even realizing
they've been directed. So if we were to take that idea, And let's just put a little
barn in here real quick. I'll just run that off the page. We'll give it that classic
barn look real quick here. All right. So you could have a fence, whatever happening
back here, treats. We could even do this.
We could even have this kind of path on this. So a diagonal. This diagonal could be coming
from a tree off camera. We don't really know. But it takes us
right into our barn. And we could indicate a little heavier shadow
underneath on this side. So you see how we
immediately follow in. Maybe we get into this path and boom, we're in
the picture clean. It was basically a
line saying go here. And then we catch the
path come into the barn. So it brings you right
in from the side. So let's talk about a
few other lead-ins. Oh, let me show you this
while I'm looking at it. So in this little city
scape we did earlier, could be a shadow
coming in here as well, from a building or whatever. Doing the same thing getting us into the picture plane. Boom, boom, boom, right around.
20. Other Lead Ins: Talk about a few other lead-ins. We can use. Again, some of these
are very classic. I've got some room here. I'll redo this. A
very common thing. Let me get some
boxes laid out here. Let's just do maybe five or six. The good old Road and pathway. We've seen this many times. I've used it here. The idea is we have a pathway that takes us to something back here. That can be coming from
different angles as well from any side that can come from the
side of the picture plane, the middle wrap in any
sort of curve works great. River or stream, you know, a river or stream connecting in, you know, just some sort
of landscape back in here. I don't know why Skip that
box. Let's go back to it. A fence. So we'll bring the
fence in from back here. Got some posts, maybe
a little crooked. You know, bring this back
in too, you know, again, it could be a barn or a little landscape or
something back in here. We've seen two where, let's say you have, you know, some sort of scene in here, and then you have
a low bright sun and we have a waterway. We'll put some sailboats. And then that reflection and the water brings us in. So that's pretty
effective as well. A row of trees works great. So we can have some trunks. Bunch of masses here. Some shadows that brings us back could be some
mountains or whatever, little house or
something in there. So that again brings
us into the painting. And let's say we
have some sort of log kind of
diagonally like that. So some sort of big
object in the foreground. A little shadow, maybe again, some sort of landscape or
whatever back in here. So that log is bringing us in to the scene and
we're coming around. Could be a tree here. Bringing us around
just like that. So all again, very useful, very traditional, tried and true ways to lead the viewer
into the painting.
21. Assignment: All right. For your assignment, I'm going to provide
a photograph, and it has three
objects, the glue, which you're familiar
with, a cup, and a box. Now, I want you to take those, rearrange them, and create
shadows that connect them. And once you do that, ask yourself, do these
things feel related now? Does the shadow create a unified shape or a
bridge between them? So that's part one
of the assignment. Part two is to create a shadow or some sort of lead in
to your arrangement, could be a foreground shadow
or perhaps even one of the object shadows coming diagonally off the
picture plane. But use that foreground
area as a lead in to the scene and
then ask yourself, does the eye follow it in? Where does it land? Is that where we want the viewer to go? Then I will complete
the same assignment.
22. Robert's Take on Lead-Ins: See, I'm burning
out a room here, but I think I can
do it right here. Bring you a little closer. So I will put a little
diagonal here for the table. I'll put my height over here. And we have our box of nails. So I think I'll put I think I'll just put our cup
over here for a second. Slightly disconnected. And then we have
our box of nails. All right. Hopefully you can see that. So we've got a shadow here
for the box of nails, and then I can run
our other shadow here and then take this one off. Again, those shadows run
up the side of it as well, which creates a
little connection. There you go. Pretty simple shadow
planes that work. What's interesting about
this too is you can easily use the background as
a unifying tool too. If I went in here and just
added a dark value mass, which is what we kind of have on that mask
behind everything. Also unifies. So that mask comes around, kind of locks in around our tin can or our cup,
locks in around this. Kind of interesting
how that works. And again, some people just look at the background
as a background. You can look at it as a tool
if you wish to. All right. So the next one, I'll do
something slightly different. And what I'll do is I think
I'll just line them up. And then maybe our box of nails. I'm going to turn
this box of nails. What is gonna have it like this. So pretty bad
composition on purpose. I'm gonna run the
shadow this way. Okay. And that shadows running
off the page a little bit. All right, so the shadows
doing their job there. Let's say we have
another shadow from something off the screen
moving across like this. Again, casting some
sort of shadow on that. So that shadow is
essentially wrapping around and moving it. I can do the same thing
with our background value. That connects the top of them. So even though these things
don't touch each other, there's no overlapping
or anything like that. It's interesting how this
shadow kind of comes in from the foreground diagonally and wraps
them together. And then this background is
doing a little work as well. Helping to unify The three objects, mainly these two.
So that's my take.
23. Simplify Busy: Not every reference
you encounter is going to hand you a
perfect composition. Most of the time,
there's a few problems. Too much going on or not enough. A busy scene overwhelms. The eye doesn't know
where to go because everything is competing
at the same volume. A dull scene underwhelms. There's no focal point, no tension, no why. Nothing pulls the viewer in. Both are editorial problems and both have
editorial solutions. This lesson covers the two most important
skills for dealing with real world references
that aren't cooperating, simplifying what's
too complicated, and adding what's missing
from something flat. These aren't techniques
for fixing bad paintings. They're thinking tools you use before the brush goes down. I'm going to pull up
your typical photograph. A complicated scene isn't a
problem with the subject. It's a problem with how much
you're trying to include. The scene has more information
than the painting needs, and your job is to edit it down to the shapes
that actually matter. The goal isn't accuracy. The goal is clarity. The painting that
includes everything the reference contains is not necessarily a
better painting. It usually is not. It's just a busier one. A good way to do
it is squinting. This will simplify the scene. Squinting kills detail
and reveals masses. What you're left with when you squint are the big value shapes. The three or four areas
of light, mid tone, darks that are actually doing
the work and the scene. These are the shapes
you're painting needs. Everything else is supporting information that
can be softened, subordinated, or cut entirely. That's probably my number
one choice, the final one. In this photo, we have
probably ten or so cars, a boat, trees, eight
or nine buildings. Typically, what happens
is someone would approach this and try to include
all of the information. So we would normally
get all the trees, all of the buildings, and
I'll just do this real quick. All of the windows, the siding, the
signage, everything. And then we get down to cars. We probably get all of the cars one here,
big truck here. We even got a boat back here. And we got a little
background sky. And then we start adding
the really small shapes, all of the windows, the tires, the figures. The clouds. And you
will see right away the signs the lines
on the street. Headlights, so on. And this thing gets
cluttered really quickly. Again, that's typically
the way an artist, especially a beginner would see. I used to see things like that. And the more I look at this, we even have this
little feature up top. I mean, it gets pretty busy, the more you look
at those details. We'll do that again. And
remember what we talked about. The why drives everything. What is it you want to say? For example, again, it
could be many things. I could look at this image and get a dozen
paintings out of it, and each one could be
slightly different. But let's just say, for
example, I want people, the viewer to come down
come down to this area. I'm going to use
the roads that's already there to this harbor. I want some really cool white
sailboats down in here. Nice dark blue, something
like that. Okay. If that's what I want, if I'm trying to create that
sort of direction, then I want to simplify. First of all, I probably
crop out half of it. And then when I squint, when I squint down and really, really pay attention
to the dark masses, the light masses, and
everything in between, what I see is one block
that does this one. I'll see another
block that does this. This is all one block. That's going to be
these dark trees in the background and this dark
mass of trees on the right. We got a medium value
in here. That's a mass. This dark here even goes right into The van. This is all I'm trying to see this all
as one mass right here. All right. So I'll shade
that in a little bit darker just so we're clear. One shape. Now, I'm looking a little
more and I'm like, Okay, I've got my
harbor down here. I've got some more lines that could lead
me down in there. I've got these posts
I run along in here, these little light posts. Then I've got the car.
Why not simplify this? I've got a car here
and let's just put one more car maybe
right in here. These cars are all
going this way, but I'm going to be
really subtle about it. Do that. Then again, we got our medium shape in here. Again, I would probably throw in some little boats back in here. And then maybe even one more car right in there, kind of grouping all
of this together. This is all medium
value, medium value. I could even run that
medium value right into this right into all these cars. And then we got this shadow even running over from the
tree over in here. That's how I want to see it. Not windows and
signs or whatever. So major shapes. And I ask
myself, would this work? If I were to just suggest a
few windows, a few doors, maybe maybe one little
pitch of a roof. Maybe one little couple of windows right in here.
That's all you need. Maybe a doorway. Just to sort of catch the back end of
that car. That's all I need. And when I paint it, I will
keep all that in mind. I would not be worried about
painting 1 million details in here because I
want you to do this. But the key here is to simplify, eliminate the clutter
and be sure whatever you include supports your Why? Everything else can go. Don't need it.
24. Add to Dull Scene: We just talked about
the busy scene and how to simplify it. Squinting and making sure
everything supports the why. That eliminates half the
problem right there. So what about the
opposite problem? A reference that's
flat, uninspiring, compositionally dead,
no clear focal point, no tension, no why. Just a scene that exists
without saying anything. The instinct is to find a better reference,
and that works. The better skill is to look at what's there and
ask what it needs. B flat scenes come up constantly and the ability to
look at something dull and see what would make it compelling is one of the most valuable things
a painter can develop. These are some of
the most common problems with scenes like this. Again, I've mentioned
a few of them, but no clear focal point. No value contrast. Perhaps it's buildings and they're all the same
value or color. Perhaps the lighting is flat, cloudy day, that sort of thing. No lead-ins, so no clear way to get into the image,
and then no why. We've already talked about
how to fix that one. Once you identify the problem you're dealing with,
you know what to add. And the more you work with
scenes and subjects you like, the more tools and
ideas you come up with. So for example, I like rustic boats and harbors
and that sort of thing. I understand how to move
piers and docks around. I understand how to add boats
and various perspectives. I've done a lot of urban scenes, so I know how to move
people around and some of the common things you
would see in cities that would help fix some
of these problems. Of course, I worked a lot
with light and shadow. I would say, most of the time, I'm changing the
light around anyway. I'm either exaggerating
it, adding it, or just moving it around to get the shadows and the
design how I want it. I could even do the
same for the buildings. You can always move
and turn buildings as well if you understand
some basic drawing skills. So we'll just take this scene, for example, and
it's a nice scene. You've got some buildings,
that could be anything. They may be
apartments, who knows? But let's say I like
the bones on it, but I want to add
something to it. Let's put the
buildings back here. I'll just do this real quick. I'm not going to copy the buildings exactly
like they are. I'll just sketch
something out here. Again, we don't want
anything right in the middle. That's a no no. Let's say I just use a rule of thirds so I can get
it quickly here. I do a series of umbrellas. We got some umbrellas in here. A little cafe scene. Now we have some life. We got people sitting, whatever. I can throw a nice
little tree in here. So greenery to sort of
carve out this corner. Now we are dealing with a city, so we can easily
have a crosswalk. Boom, taking us right on in. Find the height. You know, now we got some figures. Walking across the street. Now we have our scene, don't we? We have our lead in we have here here
taking us right to these beautiful red umbrellas or yellow or whatever
the color may be. And we've got some
people dining, a little waiter here
in a dark suit. So the why is Man, I want to be under
those umbrellas eating a dinner right now. That looks like a really
nice place to be. So that's an easy way
to take something like this and put something in there. Again, you could use this
on just about any subject. Typically, the issues come up with landscapes and cityscapes
and urban scapes and adding to it I would say happens a very
low percentage of the time. Usually, this is
what we got to do. But I love finding images of a harbor that's mainly
maybe two or three homes, cloudy day, just
nothing happening, and then tossing some boats
in there, a nice pier, a little figure there on
the pier or something, and making my own
story out of it. There's something I dil about that. They're
just hard to find. Whenever I'm out and about
and especially on vacation, I'm constantly looking
for those moments. So this sort of comes down
to an editorial thing. Both of these are
an editorial thing. Simplifying and adding
feel like opposite moves, but they come from
the same place. The understanding that you are the editor, not the recorder. The reference gives
you the raw material. Your job is to shape it into something that
communicates the Y clearly and moves the viewer through the painting
with intention. Sometimes that means cutting until only the
essential remains, which is what we did here. And sometimes it means building something that wasn't there. So the idea is you simplify the background and
add a shadow or whatever, you cut the busy detail
or add a figure. You flatten the mid
distance and push the sky. Every painting is an editing
session and opportunity.
25. Assignment: Sigan five, I'm going to
provide two references, one complicated, one dull, and you're going to create
one thumbnail for each one. Simplify the complicated scene down to three or
four big shapes. If you want to do four or five
I can live with that too. The key is to reduce. Then the second one
you can fix by adding at least one or two elements
that give it a good why. So remember on the complicated
scene, squint at it. Identify the three
big shapes or floor, do a thumbnail that
captures only those, no detail, masses, value. And a general idea where
the focal point will be. Cut everything that doesn't belong to one of your
four or five shapes. Give yourself a minute or two. It should go pretty quick. And then remember
the question, if someone squinted
at my thumbnail, would they see the clear shapes and an idea where the
focal point will be? Or is it still too busy? Of course, on the
next one, you'll take that dole reference, identify what's
missing, a focal point, some contrast, a lead in, or simply a Y. Add at least one element that addresses the biggest problem, a figure, a shadow, a foreground element, a value
shift, a lighting shift. Make it a painting that
has a reason to exist. Again, a minute or
two should be fine. Remember to ask yourself, what is this painting about now? Could I write a one
sentence Y for it? If yes, the addition worked, I'm going to complete
the same assignment.
26. Robert's Take on Assignment: Okay. I'm going to work on
the busy scene first. It's got great structure to it already, but we
know the problem. There's just too much. So
I love the crosswalk here. We have a crosswalk
coming in, great leading. Corner takes us up. And then here. So for me, the
hustle and bustle, all the shops, all the people
make that pretty good. I'm just going to make it
about these group of people maybe sitting kind of
standing right in here. So the crosswalk leads us in. O here. We'll put
this tree in there. I'll direct the shadow
across the street. And we'll have our
figures right in here. And then these buildings
will be reduced to simple, very simple. Even in the painting is going to be just very little information. So those are my basic shapes. So I'll go over this a little bit darker
so you can see it. So the biggest shape is probably
going to be right here. So these buildings maybe
stopping about there. And then we have our tree. Maybe give that a real
interesting shape coming off the camera there. And we have this shape. Getting crosswalk, taking us in. I'm just going to add this. So a shadow coming across the street,
hitting the sidewalk. And that's where our figures
will be a group of people, maybe one by themselves,
something like that. That'll be it. So that is a easy way
to simplify this, you know, and I may trickle
another figure or two, but they would be
very understated. And I think that would get
me in there. Part one. Okay, in this scene
here, great bones. I think it just needs a
little bit of life there. You know, it has that
very rustic feel, which I'm okay with. But I would like to add a
little bit of life to it. Okay. So we've got the
bar, a couple of windows. It's got this little
lean to, which is fine. You know, I don't
mind the lean to. So let's get lean to in there. And then we have our tree. I'll bring our tree down here. And then the structure maybe
even overlap in some so that tree is going to come
in front of the barn. I want to have my shadow, my son over here, and that shadow from the
tree is going to act as a lead in that diagonal
shadow cutting across. That means the shadow here, possibly a shadow under the overhang little
cast shadow here. Are the background's okay, but I can add, maybe
just some trees, a little more
activity back there. Something like
that. Tree gets us in. And just for giggles. I think I'm going to
open the barn door here. We'll do some shadows and then add maybe a couple of
figures right in here, they could be talking
about the fence that needs fixing or whatever
the case may be. But yeah, I would add a little
maybe open door that would act as a contrast for
the figures here, maybe some cast shadows,
something like that. So now I feel like this would have a
little bit better story, a little bit better
meaning for the piece. And for the masses, you
really got a large here, a medium for the
trees, then a small. A left to right. This
would be your small, I'd probably say large and
then the medium right in here, for the tree. So I think that would work good. I would definitely
give the, you know, tree some good bones here. So good amount of heavy
value to get us in there, and a nice little value
on the shadow, too. And maybe add some sort
of architectural element. Some of these barns have these really cool weather
vans and stuff on top. All right. That's my t.
27. The Blueprint and Recap: Got the tools now.
The last thing to do is to make sure they actually show up every time you sit down or
stand up to paint. That's what the blueprint is. A simple list of
questions you run through before the
brush goes down. It's not a formula. It's not a guarantee
of a perfect painting. Just a way of making sure the big decisions
are made consciously upfront instead of discovered accidentally
halfway through. Run through these every
time on a napkin, on a sketchbook, out loud in the car,
whatever works for you. So the pre painting
blueprint is what's the why? Remember, one sentence
specific and visual. What's the scale? Close
up, medium, long shot. What are the three
or four big shapes? Squint and find them. We have the rule of
thirds, traditional, and then the alternative,
small, medium, large. Is this picture plane divided horizontally and vertically? What gets cut? What's competing with or
distracting from the why? What gets added or exaggerated? What does the scene
need that isn't there? Shadows. What are
they connecting? Is there a lead in? If you've taken my
value and color course, you can ask yourself
tonal or chromatic. What sort of palette
am I going for here? What about values? Do I need to shift anything
to make this work better? The light source says the image or the reference
says the light source is here, these are all in shadows. What if I change it to here
and pull that shadow across the street to connect to my subjects? Does
that work better? Does that support
what I want to do? Anything can be changed. You're the editor. You have
to get that done. Great job. Getting through the course.
You now have a real set of tools to bring
to every painting, and more importantly, a way of thinking before the brush
ever touches the canvas. Remember, this doesn't guarantee a finished painting every time, but what it does mean is that
composition and design stop being the thing that trips
you up at the finish line. Know where you're
going to head now, what the painting is about and why you made the
decisions you made. That's a completely different
place to paint from. Thanks a lot, and I'll
see you next time.