All right! Here are three ideas for the basic layout and such.
1) A cupcake made out of an old scroll (w/ JC scribed on it) crossed by the shows two iconic swords
2) I've referenced the zombie episodes - for style: retro movie poster
3) P and J fighting off a evil cupcake
Please let me know what y'all think - what style? not clever? not bakery related enough? start over?