Transcripts
1. Introduction: How to give effective feedback? : Giving feedback is
very challenging, expensive for negative one. This way a good intention. We might stay in hertz
or discovered other. But actually we rarely
pay attention to this skill to learn
it and improve it. Is time for you to start with
the act of giving feedback. My name, CNN will leadership and personal development
China have graduate. In this court. We've been started with the
sickness, giving feedback, and how our brain
reacted to feedback, then we wouldn't learn to apply emotional intelligence, him
feedback communication. That is very half-moon
fall leaders and managers who want to give half of them feedback
for the employees. And importantly, you will learn the structure of an
effective feedback, which I call it feedback
sandwich structure. The last part we
will discuss about psychological safety
to advance this skill. After this glass, It wouldn't be able to provide feedbacks in a more thoughtful and
sensitive manner to avoid, are up there negative
emotion from dollar employees
or the audience? The possessive, this
class is very simple. Look back in the
past few months, Do you remember a
time that you gave feedback for someone but
they didn't want to take it. Another situation that you
got feedback from Sunnah now. But if stuff who defensive and you
didn't want to take it. Now after taking the course, what good food chain on those feedback to make
a situation better? Okay, now let's
start the course.
2. Signal of giving feedbacks & reactions of our brains: We actually giving
feedback all the times in our company cation in both verbal, non-verbal
communication. When I mentioned about giving
feedback and business, I think a lot of you
are gonna touch about indoor had played a situation, for example, disciplinary
conversations or when something's going wrong, or maybe our annual
evaluation with our boss. But it wasn't actually desk. Kay? You didn't realize it. When you have a conversation, you talk and you
listen to each other. In the tons of foie, the worst review the expressions and the environment we create. We are communicating feedbacks. We are telling the person in front shippers how much
we live this person, how much we respect
and we trust them, even how much we dislike, angry, I hit this person. That is part of our daily life and our working communication, but we rarely pay
attention to this skill. I know is very challenging. It's not easy at all expenses when we have
to give negative feedback. So I can see that a lot of
people actually avoid giving negative feedback so that
they don't have to deal with negative reactions
from the audience. They said was a powerful people might not remember every detail, every word that you say to them, but they will never forget
how you make them feel. You've the words of feedback smartly, effectively
and contractive. Flee. I myself, I went looking for getting
constructive feedback to help me improve
my performance. But I actually stand, remember, there were a lot
of time that I got feedbacks for mothers
that I feel hurt. I feel disappointed. A few MIT understood. It spells a few attack. Those moment I own way
have to tell myself that. Don't take it personally. Focused on the learning
intentions of Dell feedback, which is still hot. It's very hard and it's
uncomfortable feeling. I wonder if we really
know how to provide feedback in a more
sensitive, effective ways. We might avoid those
negative feelings from our receiver, our audience. We also create the environment
that everyone can open, say opinions, and learn
and grow together. Now look back at the time that I asked you at
the beginning of the course. Do we remember a moment that you GFC back
from the others? But if Phil, if you want to listen or
during one, detect it. What was the reason? Was his biggest test person
say something told me wrong? This make their own assumptions
or judgments about you. Or the way that they
deliver the extract, their feedbacks make
you feel uncomfortable. They are two common situation that you're going to get not
very effective feedback. The first equation is when the feedback is
Tuesday, January, to soften indirect that the
person in front of you, they didn't rely that they
have feedback given for them. They didn't focus. And think about
how to improve it. The second situation is
when you give a feedback but to direct or you
use so aggressive word, you add the owner assumption
judgment on their feedback. And you see that people
start getting defensive. That is very common reactions when our brain fill
light, we attack. How could we do this better? Let the scatter about it.
3. Before giving a feedback?: Before giving feedback, Let's start with the question, why? If you want to make sure that
you are going to provide a very meaningful and
feedback for the audience. Let's step back a little bit. And remember why
you really want to give feedback to that
person at the first place. Because you want to have this person to improve
in what they do. If so, when it's time for
you to give feedback, let focus less on the person, but more on what the person wants to accomplish.
What are their goals? Our goal, our team role. Your students say
that this wrong, That's person did this wrong. But rather at noon is what
they have been doing so far. And the intention is having them to get better
result in the future. A lagging the feedbacks
with the audience goals is his cruiser for them to
really want to listen to you. Because when they
realized though, good intention that you want to have them to
achieve their goal. That's what motivate
them to listen. Thus me, that you also
need to take time to really understand
the audience or the employee goals to be able
to provide more practical, meaning, 4.51 feedback, which
are alive with their goal. Some of you might say that
a high don't have town. Bz, I'm a manager or leader. I have to deal with
many other things. But you have to recognize that taking time to
have a communication, meaningful communication
with the employees, to really understand
their debt career goal, what they want to
accomplish in the future. That is very, very important
roles at a leader. That's where not only be
able to help you to provide more meaningful and helpful
feedback for the employees. For also have you in many other ways that you may
come to the case at a team. So take time to do it. Now it'd be realised
that you are not good yet at giving
feedback to the others. Take time to practice
it in advance. Prepare the feedback
in advance though that you have time to think about what you're
gonna say and how could be the best way
for you to deliver it. It says a skilled near time to practice until it
becomes a habit, then you could delivery very sensitive constructive
feedback naturally, instantly in any situation.
4. Use your emotional intelligent: I have been teaching
emotional intelligence for a lot of leaders
and wondered the most important aspect of emotional intelligence
is impetigo. Impetigo here mean you suppose the cell in other
perspective before reacting. Way easy to talk then
do we often make command before we actually considering what could
this person has been to. Before you making any feedback, try to put yourself in the other person's perspective before you actually saying it. For example, there of saying a very long aggressive feedback up the reason why the person
will late for the meeting. Good. It resists asking the college
what was happening to them. Is everything okay? Anything that you could help
them in this situation. And now the exam
board that before I was saying that you dislike a person performing whatever
you could consider, what could be the
possible challenge that person is facing now, and anything that you could have them too, so they're full-blown. I cannot stress it enough debt don't make
the owner assumption of judgment before
you actually have a chance to listen
to the person story. When they realized that we actually can't we here to help, their willingness to hear a different opinion
could start opening up.
5. What can I learn from? : We were discussing before, one of the purpose of
giving feedback to other is just helping them
to learn and improve. To be able to help out the pupil to learn
from our feedback. Feedback needs to be specific
enough to the environment, to this deviation are not so alive with they are gone
that we were discussing. People love to hear a sincere and honest
appreciation statement, but it needs to be specific. For example, instead
of the same good job, you could actually more
detail in doors statement. For example. I see it today you already at market data to
adopt presentation, which make it clear
the market situation. Thank you for that. Could be a lot more specific for the audience to really
know what aspect, what details are, what
task has been doing well, to be able to continue their
good job in the future. Even try harder to improve their performance
in the future. As similar to that, giving negative feedback on the negative positive
feedback is also meant to be specific enough for them to really know wished. And I wrote a new to improve. Don't say this to
Xander of light. Did a terrible job. They could not learn from it. They don't really know
what specific tasks needed to improve here. Then you could add the
conversation later. What could be the solution
to have them to improve their error above
the negative paths. We will discuss it a
little bit later in detail because it's a more challenging paths
of giving feedback.
6. Sandwich structure_ the 1st layer : Now it's time to talk about the structure of an
effective feedback. I call it the feedback
sandwich structure. Similar to 3D layer or sandwich. We also have three parts
of our feedback structure. The bottom layer, we talk
about our CNC accomplishment. The middle layers is where
we are talking about the error that the
person needs to improve. That is the more
challenging part when we're talking about the
narrative of it. And the top layer,
we win chiral, our sandwich with the
room for questions. And the area that
we can give them some suggestions or option for day to improve
their performance. Let's start with the first
part of our Lewis structure. The bottom layer. The complainant
pupil will listen to you when they feel like
they are understood and OPC. Filling up what
they mean saying or doing have some former values. When you provide
feedback for them, you suit make them feel
bored of that aspect. So let us start with
the complainant. Feedback is an opportunities
for us to provide our appreciations
and motivations for our team, for our audience. It's time for you to
sell the PCAs and for all of the good job that
they've been doing, That's when have them have
the motivation to continue their good job and unsere were harder to achieve better
results in the future. However, not many leaders and managers really pay
attention to sewing the speciation of the grid thing that the employee
has been doing. They assume that their employee
job to do all of that. Therefore, they're
missing the opportunity to inspire positive feeling for the employee on so missing the opportunity to
view the connection with them. In terms of giving complement, this should be given in
a very sincere manner. As sued, not be too general. Good job. It did it good because the person would not
learn anything from that. And also when you say
it in his two Zander, a way people are gonna
think that it's not really since the accompaniment or
maybe it's just a fake one. We say that people need to feel they are understood
and appreciated. But we could pay attention
to our language, to sewing board of bad aspect. For example, when you
want to sell you, I really understand
their situation. You could say something
like yeah, I see. Oh, I got it. I will facing
the same challenge before. I see because I also have
the same issue before. When you want to say that
you are really a PC, the job that they've been doing, you can say something
like white symbol. The job you have been doing as very important to our team. Presenters today, sewing,
very entraining fire view, we open now, my
thank you for that.
7. Sandwich structure_ the second layer : Now we go to the meadow pattern
bile feedback structures. That error that the
person could improve. This the most challenging
part of giving feedback. Because people on way avoid talking about
narrative thing so that they don't
have to deal with negative emotions or
reaction from the audience. But if you want to have the other person to really learn and improve in
their performance, we need to be sincere, flee, provide our opinions
about the area that they could improve so that they could make a better programmer
in the future. When you being able to provide
the negative aspects of their feedback in a very sincere
and non-constructive way the person could on.So, want to open their
mind and start listening to a different
opinions because they can feel Dao good intention that helping them to
improve themselves. When you're saying about the
negative parts of feedback, try to pay attention
to language and tone. It is very important because it's very sensitive
when you're saying both negative thing and dot voice and the
language you used, maybe make the meat understood
the good intention. You know, you cannot
influence someone if you have adjustments
about that person. So it's very important that your pseudonym have any
assumption or judgment, the situation or about that person before you
making the feedback. To be able to give an
effective feedback. Focus lead in the persons
but more in the ECUs. And we go forward. The practical solution
to solve that problem. Because if you really lay, make an assumption and
talking about what the person did wrong, the person could fill
a personal attack. A way to helping
them to improve. It can take one example. You can new machine. For example, someone giving
them feedback, ladies. The customer wasn't
happy with ourselves. I guess. You didn't know how to
talk with the customer. Maybe you didn't
know anything above or to be able to consult
with the customer. So we can see disasters totaling not coach active
and 1.5 feedback. Let me discuss
what's the area that disease fish back is
wasn't very well. First when he was
just saying that the customer wasn't
happy with our service, is this Tuesday and lower is not specific enough for
the person to really understand which
particular aspect of our services that they need
to improve in the future. The second part is also
the most serious path. That is this mic, the owner assumption about das person instead
of listening to really know what will happening or what was their stories. But he's just make the
own assumption that you assume that that
wasn't didn't really know how to talk with
the customer on, didn't know about our product to provide good service
for the customer. By talking in that
way and making the owner assumption before you really listened to their person, you can make the person feel
like it's a personal attack. They wouldn't feel
worse about themselves. Because you didn't listen to them before they make
their own conclusion, since they also feel like they are not
understood our listen. Let's see how we can improve the feedback
in this situation. For example, instead of data, we can say something like
the customer will feel in our evaluation form that they wasn't happy about our
consulting services. Maybe we could go together to
make our own evaluation of our survey to see which arrow we could have
done better in the future. You can see what improve. In the second feedback here. You saying that the
customer was unhappy about the consulting
service with the second data
that the customer fill in the evaluation form and specify that it wasn't happy
about the consulting survey. You add thing FAQ and data in the feedback is make the
feedback really clear. And validate is not
something that you assume. A2s anaerobes. They know that they need to
focus on customer service. Here is the routing Soviet. The good part about
this feedback. If that's you didn't really
focus on the person, but rather this
focus on the ECU. It remove the person from
the feedback and the resists talking about what
we need to improve here. Another good point
of this feed packet that you're including dorsal to the Portland by
saying that maybe we can evaluate this to care there, to see what we can
improve in the future. By saying that you
mean that you are here to have them together with
them to sell our problem. So is really sewing
the understanding and the good intention to have the person to get a better
result in the future. When they know the
good intentions. And they really see
that the attitude is here to have the
grid really OPC, that the wins that open up and discard
the solvers in which you to get a better result in the performance
in the future.
8. Sandwich structure_ the third layer : Okay, now so we go
to the top part, the top layer of the
sandwich structure. Wishart the room for us to ask questions and have a conversation
to pull by structure. Since an option for the person
to improve their arrows. Asking questions is a
good way for you to really understand why
they have the DAS ECU. You also understand what the challenge or issue
that they are facing. So you can be able to provide any support and help
for them if they need. It's also a good
opportunities for you to care to have the, the
two-way feedback. It's not like one way uses talk and make the owners
sons into desk person. But actually you have
them to really open up. That new guy had the
board way feedback and the mutual understanding
with each other and together to solve the zoo. So I can take one example. For example, one person
giving a feedback glaze is that sales is
money, terrible. I don't care what he's gonna do, but go **** it. I need the sale target to rich
by the end of this month. How would how would that
kind of feedback is not uncontracted and a
half for feedback at all to the employees
or the team memory. First, pay attention
to the tones of voice. You are talking in a way that
you are criticizing them. It's a very aggressive voice
that you're talking to them. Does so no understanding. Note impetigo. Second, we should pay attention to the language
that we are using. Is this saint yet their
sales, this many terrible. You ignore the group Pat or the boot performance
you did in the past. You didn't care. Use this focus that this month is terrible. So that's mean that this
person did a terrible job. Not a good way for encouraged and sewing the
appreciations and agony Xmin. The good job that the
person would wane way. More important part. Keep them. No options if sowing no
understanding to the person. It was this say to
them, I don't care what will happening.
I don't know. I don't care what you gonna do to fix the bulk lips, go do it. It's a way for you to release so that understanding and really listen to the person's story. I can get if you put themselves in the situation of the
employees or the team member. And the boss was saying,
how good you feel. Of course. Is the
fillings a long lease, filming up, not being
heard or understood. No one could be motivated to really work harder
and try their best to. So the ECU in that situation, saying the feedback lines, I choose this fruit more
presser for the employees. This is not half-full
at are for them. Instead, you could say something like say We're really great
in the past few months. I were very happy with top performance in
the past few months. This man as a seeing that those who had
dropping about 30%, worry about you and coming
to us if everything's okay. Anything that I can have
use in the situation. You can see the different way. First, in the way you
revert the feedback in the tones of voice
showing that you care and you had to have. And secondly, the focus in the
language that we're using. First, we appreciate what they did well in
the past few men, this man, we're seeing some ECU. We worry about that
person and we come to offer support. How
would that cell? That's person good, Really, really OPC it that they win, start opening up, setting
with you what trouble, what challenge that they're facing and if their
boss or their leaders, you can really support
them and provider have or advice for them in this DUAs
him to get a better result. That's soup. Be the way the
feedback stoop go. Now we're talking about the
axon a BDT of our feedback. Because it's very important. We purify our feedback
here to be able to describe the error
that we could improve. When we provide our
feedback is to be in a way that we can
learn and we can move forward with the actionable
and practical solution for our Quran ECO. Before you give a
feedback to someone, what attributes are resolved you are expecting and hoping to get. After this conversation? Like we discussed before we
start with question, why Ray? What the result
you wanted to get, what the improvement of the ECU want to achieve
after this conversation. Then after we discard the ECU, we've moved toward to
the practical solution. That's good beat the best
intentions of a good feedback. Symbol when you learn that the employees feeling
lonely to deal with customer usage by themselves when they
still new to the team. What could be the adjustment
or the chain that you could make to be able to provide
better support to this person. For example, you could give more time to
talk with the person weekly or daily to be able to provide support when
they really need. You can assign someone to work closely with this person to support them until
they feel confident to work by themselves. By sewing that we're willing
to make chain together. To Fick the program together, you will create the room for the improvement
individually and as a team.
9. The Psychological Safety: Now we're talking
about the cycle of these safety to be able to
give effective feedback. You know, a lot of pupil, they are so upset about making sure that
they've being right. But they didn't realize that being right is
not important things. There are some study already saw that in a good
performance teams, everyone in the team, they feel safe to be able
to say or their idea. They will not have to worry that they would be punished if
they making a mistake. So that they can freely
express their opinions, try and new ideas and giving a different
feedback to each other. Two rows and learn at a team
that is very important. But if you're making a
feedback in a negative way, people could meet understanding or they would feel that you are criticizing them
for making a mistake. They weren't that close off. And they will be getting more defensive and didn't really
want to say or listen. So the second pass I wanted to, this guy here is waves
to provide feedback. You can name as in, is this a good situation
for you to really provide an aggressive
long feedback for someone or person did wrong. Or you disagree with in
a really big group of crowded a group of pupil in a different
team in a company. How good the person
could fill were filled by a person who
attack the person good. Feel like they are
publicly seen. Not a good feeling for them to open and listen
to the feedback. And they will start getting. Let us confidence few words about themselves or
start getting defensive. Therefore, you might
consider giving negative feedback in private
so that you're going to have the environment for safe environments for you to discover closely
the issue together, to really understand the
situation and be able to gather providers solution
to freak the Buchla. The last spots is how you can deal with the
tangents population. We might not be able to successful honor time in the winter we're giving
feedback to other. Sometimes our feedback
get meat understood, our people interpreted
in a giffen way. In that situation is sued in
try to drag this person in. Endless argument is not
a good point to do that. And if you feel like you
have a chalkboard to expand the opinions that a lot of time that people meet understood
what you were saying. You could really think
about fighting, of course, mentor to help you better
at expressing dollar ideas. In a situation when
we pulled buying feedback to each other and
you start filling defensive. Or you can realize that the receiver start
getting defensive. It's time for you to be
relaxed a little bit, step back a little bit, move up to another level. They tried to enjoy on the error or the pie
that you bought Orion, that you wouldn't create more comfortable environments
to remove all that tension. All will remember your team. You are as a team, you're here to support and have a charter
to learn in growth. You only try to create an environment that everyone
feels safe for them to really say that
their opinion said their idea and get
an defense aspect of different opinions because
they understand that we are here to help each other to
learn in growth at a team. That is the most
important thing. This is also the
end of the course and I hope that you already get some more information
for you to be able to practice giving an effective and constructive
feedback in the future, lead practices and
pay attention to this important skill to
be able to improve it. I'm so that when you
making it at a habit, you can be able to provide feedback
effectively, contractive, least insensitive manner in any stepwise and even in
the world, daily life. Bys and see you in
another course.