2026 Etsy Success Killers: 10 Outdated Things You Must Stop Doing | Shubham Jain | Skillshare

Playback Speed


1.0x


  • 0.5x
  • 0.75x
  • 1x (Normal)
  • 1.25x
  • 1.5x
  • 1.75x
  • 2x

2026 Etsy Success Killers: 10 Outdated Things You Must Stop Doing

teacher avatar Shubham Jain, Everything about Etsy & Social Media

Watch this class and thousands more

Get unlimited access to every class
Taught by industry leaders & working professionals
Topics include illustration, design, photography, and more

Watch this class and thousands more

Get unlimited access to every class
Taught by industry leaders & working professionals
Topics include illustration, design, photography, and more

Lessons in This Class

    • 1.

      Introduction

      0:55

    • 2.

      1st Mistake

      1:30

    • 3.

      2nd Mistake

      1:16

    • 4.

      3rd Mistake

      1:38

    • 5.

      4th Mistake

      1:33

    • 6.

      5th Mistake

      1:23

    • 7.

      6th Mistake

      1:53

    • 8.

      7th Mistake

      2:18

    • 9.

      8th Mistake

      1:43

    • 10.

      9th Mistake

      1:25

    • 11.

      10th Mistake

      1:53

    • 12.

      Outro

      0:42

  • --
  • Beginner level
  • Intermediate level
  • Advanced level
  • All levels

Community Generated

The level is determined by a majority opinion of students who have reviewed this class. The teacher's recommendation is shown until at least 5 student responses are collected.

58

Students

--

Projects

About This Class

Are you still using outdated strategies on Etsy that no longer bring results? Many sellers unknowingly hold onto old habits that quietly kill visibility and sales. This class uncovers the 10 outdated things sellers are still doing in 2025 — and what to do instead.

In this course, you’ll learn:

  • The most common outdated SEO practices holding sellers back

  • Listing mistakes that lower visibility in search

  • Old sales tactics that no longer match Etsy’s algorithm

  • What modern strategies successful sellers use today

Each lesson is clear, actionable, and focused on helping you avoid mistakes that keep shops stuck. You’ll not only learn what to stop doing, but also how to replace these outdated habits with smarter approaches that align with Etsy’s current marketplace.

If your traffic feels low, sales inconsistent, or your shop is plateauing, this course will give you the clarity to pivot. Stay ahead of the competition, avoid common pitfalls, and position your shop for sustainable growth on Etsy.

Interested in personalized support for your Etsy store?
Whether you're looking for a one-on-one consultation or want to hire me as a virtual assistant to help manage and grow your Etsy shop, feel free to reach out through the platforms below:

I’d be happy to discuss how I can support your Etsy journey!

Meet Your Teacher

Teacher Profile Image

Shubham Jain

Everything about Etsy & Social Media

Teacher

Hi, I'm Shubham! With over 5 years of experience selling on Etsy and working as an Etsy consultant, I've helped more than 50 sellers optimize their shops, improve SEO, and increase sales. From crafting high-converting product listings to mastering Etsy's algorithm, I know what it takes to turn a struggling shop into a thriving business. My goal is to simplify Etsy's complexities and provide actionable strategies that actually work.

On Skillshare, I share step-by-step courses designed to help both new and experienced Etsy sellers boost visibility, attract more customers, and scale their business. Whether you're struggling with SEO, product photography, or marketing, my courses will give you the insights and tools you need to succeed. Let's unlock your Etsy shop's full potential to... See full profile

Level: All Levels

Class Ratings

Expectations Met?
    Exceeded!
  • 0%
  • Yes
  • 0%
  • Somewhat
  • 0%
  • Not really
  • 0%

Why Join Skillshare?

Take award-winning Skillshare Original Classes

Each class has short lessons, hands-on projects

Your membership supports Skillshare teachers

Learn From Anywhere

Take classes on the go with the Skillshare app. Stream or download to watch on the plane, the subway, or wherever you learn best.

Transcripts

1. Introduction: You've been selling on Etsy for a while and your sales have platade or words started to decline, you're not alone. The truth is what worked on Etsy four to five years ago doesn't work today the same way. The platform evolves, the competition grows and the buyer behavior shifts. As an Isi consultant, I see many Isi sellers using the same outdated strategies. It quietly hurt their visibility and long term growth. This course is here to change that. We're going to walk through ten common but outdated practices that Isi sellers still rely on oftentimes without realizing that they're holding their stores back. You will walk away with a clear understanding of what to stop doing actionable steps to update your listing, branding and marketing, a checklist to help you spot and fix these issues across your entire shop. 2. 1st Mistake: Using plain white background images. Now, I get it. This used to be the standard, clean, minimal, and distraction free. It worked very well on platforms like Amazon and Ebay, so naturally people carried that over to Ex. But here's the problem. Is is a visual search engine for creative products. Your listing is surrounded by dozens, if not, hundreds of similar products. And when every thumbnail looks the same, your product just blends in. What Itsy shoppers are looking for is connection. They want to feel something. They want to imagine your product in their life, a candle in a cozy living room, a necklace on real skin, a print hanging in a styled space. That's where the lifestyle images come in. These show your product in context, tell a story, and catch attention way faster than a plain white square. Now, this doesn't mean the white background images are completely off limits, but they should not be your main thumbnail ever. Use style shots, brand colored backdrop or flat lace to make your product pop. Show scale, show texture, and show some personality because on ICU not just selling a product, you're selling a feeling. So if most of your images are on plain white backgrounds, it's time for a visual upgrade. 3. 2nd Mistake: Writing short unoptimized titles. Let's say you've listed a beautiful handmade ceramic mug, and your title just says cute handmade mug. Sounds nice, right? But no one is searching for this phrase, and Isi algorithm has no idea what your product is exactly about. Titles on Isi are one of the biggest ranking factors, and if you're not using them well, you're leaving sales on the table. Now, I agree that short titles may look very clean and visually appealing, but they don't get your product anywhere. Instead of just describing what the item is, think as a buyer of what they might search for when they're looking for your product. For example, instead of cute handmade mug, try personalized ceramic coffee mug. Use the word personalized only if your product offers personalization. Boho floral design, gift for mom, custom name cup. This is a sample title that I've written now, Dad's keyword rich. Its will not penalize you for writing long titles as long as they're relevant and readable. Remember, your title is not just a label. It's your first shot at being found. Use it wisely. 4. 3rd Mistake: Not using informational images. Most Etsy sellers focus on making their product images look beautiful, and that's great. But if your entire listing is just one pretty picture after another, you're missing a great opportunity. The opportunity to educate and convert your customer. Remember, customers can't touch, hold, or try a product in person, and most of them will never ever read a product description. So it's your job to give them all the relevant information visually. That's where the informational images come in. These are the slides that combine your product photos with helpful text or graphics like size guides, material used, key features, care instructions, what's included in the package, comparison shots. Or you can say before and after size A or size B. And yes, people do read these when they're embedded into the listing images. Why? Because it's easier and faster than digging through your product description. Here's the truth. A customer should fully understand your product by just swiping through your listing images. Your goal is to eliminate uncertainty and build trust, and images are the fastest way to do that. 5. 4th Mistake: Overwriting product descriptions. Though shall not try to write like Shakespeare, when you're trying to write Itsy descriptions, you don't have to work this hard. This is something I see wrong with Itsy sellers, especially the passionate ones. Now, don't get me wrong. Being detailed is great, but writing long, flowery essay style descriptions is not helping your sales at all because most Izzy buyers will never ever read your description, rather, they just skim through it. And if your description is just a giant block of text, you've already lost them. So here's what to do instead. Break your description into clear sections like product details, sizing information, shipping and care instructions. Use bullet points to highlight features and benefits like I'm doing now. Put the most important information in the first two lines. That's what shows up in the preview under your title. Avoid repeating what's already obvious from your images. Instead, focus on answering common questions and reducing doubts. And most importantly, write for clarity, not for creativity. Your description should be short, skimable and focused on conversion. 6. 5th Mistake: Hiding behind the brand. A lot of Itsy sellers keep their shop very product focused. No photo of the maker, no personal touch, and definitely no information about the owner. It's all just logos, listings, and neutral branding. And while that does look professional, you're missing out on one of the biggest advantages of using Its daddy's personal connection. People don't just buy products in Its. They buy from the makers, from the artist, from you. So when you stay hidden behind your branding, buyers feel like they're shopping from a faceless business rather than a real person. And that's exactly what the buyers are trying to avoid by coming onto EDS instead of Amazon. Here's what builds trust, a clear, smiling photo of you in your shop banner or profile, a short shop video showing your process of workspace, a warm, honest about section that tells your story and passion, even handwritten thank you notes or signature in your packaging. These small touches make your shop instantly more likable and more personal because when buyers connect with you, they're more likely to shop from you and become a repeat customer. 7. 6th Mistake: Ignoring social media. A lot of Izzy sellers believe that if they focus only on uploading great products and optimizing their listings, sales will come. While that might have worked five years ago, it does not work today. Here's the truth. Itsy alone is not a real growth strategy anymore. You're competing with thousands of shops selling similar products. You're not alone in the market anymore. You're competing with thousands of shops selling similar products. And Izzy algorithm favors listings that already have traffic and engagement. If you're not driving people to your shop outside from Its, you're already falling behind. That's where social media comes in, Instagram, YouTube shots, TikTok, if it still works for you, and Pinterest. That is where your customers already are. They're scrolling, they're discovering, and they're buying. Oftentimes using reels or YouTube shots when they see something and they find it interesting, they buy. Here's what to share on your social media. Share behind the scenes of your process. Show how your product is made or used. Share packaging, studio updates, or your creative workspace. Reuse your videos across multiple platforms for maximum reach. Social content helps build trust and makes people fall in love with your brand even before they land on your listing. So if you've been putting social media off for a while, saying, I don't have enough time or whatever, it doesn't require that much time, and you're missing out on one of the biggest tools of this generation because in today's world, content is equal to visibility. 8. 7th Mistake: Not using price psychology. For a lot of people, what price psychology is labeling their product with the cheapest price tag that they can. But you have to remember, people don't always buy the cheapest thing. They buy what they feel like is the best deal, and that is where the price psychology comes in. I have two simple strategies that you can follow and benefit from. Strategy number one is price anchoring. This is where you intentionally list one variation of your product at a lower price. Knowing most people will not buy it. Now, as an example, let's talk about this listing in particular. If you scroll here, it says, digital download for $9. So if you click away, the pricing, when we are searching for this, it only shows $9 here outside and for $9, it's cheap. When you click on it and finally go through the options, you realize that it's just digital download for $9 and rest of the printed options are listed at their respective prices. What this does is it hooks buyers in by showing a cheaper price point. So at least it improves engagement by a lot. And that's what I use, and that's what most of the sellers I see use today. Strategy number two is daily sale pricing. What you do is, for example, you're trying to run a daily 25% of sales. What you do is increase your product price by 33.33% and then run a 25% discount. You will reach your original price. You just trying to present your deal in a more compelling way, nothing else. And when it combines with a countdown timer, because you are running sales every single day for 24 hours, when you combine it, it just becomes irresistible and it makes people buy impulsively. Again, I admit it's a very ****** tactic, ******, but it works. So it doesn't matter. 9. 8th Mistake: Neglecting mobile optimization. Here's something most Itsy sellers forget. Over 60% of the traffic comes from mobile devices. This means most of your potential customers are scrolling through their tiny phone screens rather than big laptops or desktops. But if you're designing your branding your informational images only for the bigger screens, you're hurting your conversions. If your product images are not square, they may look, honestly terrible on the mobile screen. If you're adding text as an overlay on multiple of your listing images, make sure it's readable and legible on your smartphone displays as well. Here's what to do. Always use square images, especially for your first thumbnail and for all the images because square images look the best on smartphones and on desktop. Adding text to images, use large bold fonts. Keep it minimal, but make sure that the font is readable. Review your listing on your phone before publishing. Zoom out when designing to mimic the mobile viewing experience. You want your listings to look clean and legible, even on a six inch screen. This is your reminder that mobile comes first, because now it's 60% of the customers viewing through smartphone devices. I'm pretty sure that in four or five years, it's going to cross 70% or even 75, 80%. 10. 9th Mistake: Not using reviews visually. So many sellers work really hard to get those five star reviews. But then they just leave them there in the reviews tab. Here's the truth. Buyers trust other buyers more than they trust you. Social proof is powerful and it should be a part of your listing images. Here's how to do it. Take your best one to two sentence reviews and turn them into branded image slides. Overlay the review text on a photo of your product or use a clean background with a customer photo. Highlight keywords buyer care about great quality, fast shipping, exactly what I expected or something like that. Someone shares a photo in their reviews, you can also include it in your image gallery. Why is this so effective? Because when buyers are flipping through your images, they are still deciding. Seeing a glowing review right then and there can seal the deal. It's especially powerful if you use this photo at the near end of your photo set. Think of it as a final trust boost that can make them click on at Tocart. Remember. Remember what other people say about you sells better than what you say about yourself. 11. 10th Mistake: Not building a loyalty or an email strategy. Let me ask you this. What happens when someone buys from your store? If your answer is, they get their order and that's it. You're missing out on a huge opportunity because the easiest person to sell to is someone who's already bought from you before. But so many Etsy sellers make this mistake of treating sale as a one time event. No follow up, no offer to come back, no incentive to staying connected. Let's fix that. Here are a few loyalty strategies that you can use on your EtS store. Send a thank you coupon to every customer after purchase. You can do this automatically with Its's thank you coupon feature. If you're running 20 or 25% sales like I generally do, you can offer 5% extra off to them to encourage repeat business. Turn favorites into sales, enable favorite discount. So people who favorite your item get an instant coupon. You're catching them while they're interested and it's perfect timing. Recover lost sales, turn on abandoned card discounts. It's even email customers who added your item to card but didn't check out. With a little nudge in the form of coupon. And if you want to go beyond Etsy, build an email list using packaging inserts, digital downloads or a freebie link. This gives you long term control, so you're not 100% dependent on Itzs traffic. Loyalty is not about spamming customers. It's about building relationships and giving your happy customers a reason to come back. So if you're always chasing new buyers rather than cherishing the ones you already have, it's time to start now. 12. Outro: Now learned ten outdated strategies Its sellers still rely upon and how to fix them with ease. But information is only half the battle. You know what really moves the needle implementation. But remember, information is only half the battle. You know what really moves the needle implementation. My name is ShibumJan, and if you're ready to book a consultation or need help with your SEO or want a full Is shop audit, you can connect with me on LinkedIn or on Upwork. I'd love to help you take your shop to the next level. Thanks for watching.